is Trigun Stampede Really THAT BAD?

Hope you feel better seastatics

I remember the original feeling sci fi and more a western I think I might enjoy this more

I didn’t care about Millie in the original too much she wasn’t a bad character she didn’t feel too important to me so her being taken out didn’t bother me

…

EMBRACE THE NEW! CGI is the future

I haven’t watched the original Trigun, do I need to watch that one before this?

I will give a chance for this anime, a lot of moments look really good, but… I don't like they tell almost everything about this world and characters right in the first episode. Original Trigun was interesting because every episode you got know something new about the characters, about the world, about motivation, etc… And it starts as a little comedy, but finished as a big drama. I really liked how it felt.

Hate the character design… just to Apple seed for my taste.
I am however reserving judgement on story changes until S1 is done.
Long story short I fear for Wolfwood's treatment but am not sold on Vashes new character either.
I think its to early to say straight forward worse or better than OG. But I am leaning towards worse… They simply have changed to much and my girl Mili Thompson is gone which is unforgivable.
Also the lack of the black cat each episode is noticed and not appreciated.
To serious.
Despite my complaints I am watching with the mind set of purposefully not comparing since its a reboot basically.

Milli was very important to the emotion of the OG… Merol not so much.
Milli was like a modern day Rem and we all know how important Rem was to Vash.
Merols denial makes sense also.
Vash is supposed to be a monster and our donut loving madman is no monster. She kept seeing him as unfortunately sharing a name.

The Manga explained the Plants pretty much right off the bat so in that sense this version is more like the manga. Like the new design for the plants.
Seem less human so its easier to get why people treat them like slaves.
In case you forgot the OG vash and Knives are either plants themselves or at least partially like plants which explained their Angel Cannons power I think.
I wonder if they changed that?

It's a good anime, being cgi, it has less "details"(For now, there's no bullet holes or blood, for example), but you can do more "cool shoots"(like the chase scene).

An this is a different anime than the "original".

Sometimes less is more and the original having not that much material to work with made the anime more about the people and the "environment"(social, political, etc?) outside the plants.
Vash was a mistery and unraveling more of "The Humanoid Typhoon" was really interesting aside from every other character.

Here there's no much mistery and because there's no build up, the impact it's not the same. But having 20139094034 animes of isekai pc mc, this is a "fresh" thing.

For me, Vash's arm (in the original) served as another mistery, because not only he lose his arm, but his entire body was a mess.
Idk what they would show us about his arm in this anime, so we can only wait.

PD: Also, I may be stupid, but what was the poit of firing the cluster bombs? If everyone was running for their life (and they weren't even close).. what about the one who fired? He and Vash where certainly close enough to die together., so what exactly his plan? suicide?

In terms of pacing, its too forced. It throws everything up front without reason. Its like going a first date and your date telling proposing to you. But I guess people are into that kind of stuff.